|
In a scant few years,
D.J. Casser's Black Diamond Racing has risen from relative obscurity
to the upper echelon of audio tweakdom. Having
almost singularly pioneered the use of carbon fiber for damping and
resonance control in audio applications, Casser has recently turned
his attention to the world of analogue playback, where the control of
micro-vibrations and resonances is of the utmost importance. The Round
Things record clamp is the latest member of Black Diamond Racing's
unimaginatively named, yet justly famous, stable of carbon fiber
resonance control products, which includes The Shelf, Those Things and
the Mk.III and Mk. IV Pyramid Cones.
The Round Things clamp
is a two-piece affair consisting of a thin circular disc, dubbed the "coaster",
and a thick rounded puck, both fashioned from carbon fiber and
finished in a high gloss. Holes drilled through the center of both
components (unthreaded in the case of the coaster, threaded via a
brass insert in the case of the puck) accept a turntable spindle ¼"
in diameter with a thread density of twenty threads per inch - a
configuration chosen for compatibility with VPI's array of turntables.
The coaster, in the words of D.J. Casser, "is the interface
portion of the clamp", designed to be sandwiched between the LP's
label area and the threaded puck. The bottom of the coaster contains a
recessed area, said to aid in the coupling of record and clamp, and
its edge is beveled to forty-five degrees so as to provide adequate
clearance during a cartridge's traversal of the LP's runout groove.
Although the Round Things record clamp will work with turntables other
than those from VPI (provided, of course, that the spindle is of the
appropriate dimensions), I would caution owners of non-VPI turntables
to ensure that their turntable's motor is able to cope with its
relatively high mass (about fifty-percent greater than that of the
stock VPI clamp) before proceeding.
Associated
Components
Analog:
VPI Aries turntable, Audioquest tonearm, Benz-Micro MC Gold moving
coil cartridge, Black Diamond Racing "Round Things"
record clamp Preamplifier:
Audible Illusions Modulus 3A with John Curl designed gold MC phono
board Power
Amplifiers: Celeste Moon W-5, Sonic Frontiers Power 2
Loudspeakers: ProAc Studio 150, Meadowlark Audio
Shearwater Cables:
XLO Type 4 digital cable, D Lin Audio Silver Bullets 4.0
interconnects, Transparent Audio MusicWave Plus loudspeaker
cables, Cardas Hex 5C phono interconnect.
Accessories: Echo Busters room treatment products, Lead(less)
Balloon turntable stand with Air Head isolation base, Target
equipment stands, Black Diamond Racing Mk.III and Mk.IV Pyramid
Cones, Nitty Gritty 2.5Fi Mk.II record cleaning machine, Nitty
Gritty Pure-2 cleaning fluid, Stylast stylus treatment, 15A
dedicated AC outlets. |
While the clamp was not
accompanied by any form of user documentation (a side-effect of the
review sample's early production origins, I suspect), its use is quite
obvious. With an LP on the turntable's platter, the coaster is lowered
over the spindle until it comes into contact with the LP's label area.
The puck is then threaded onto the turntable's spindle and tightened
against the top surface of the coaster, the latter being held firmly
so that it is not allowed to rotate against, and hence wear, the LP's
label. When the clamp is used with one of VPI's turntables, the rubber
spindle washer used in conjunction with the stock VPI clamp should be
left in place, preventing any "dishing" of the clamped vinyl
disc. Although the two-piece, and hence two-handed, nature of the
Black Diamond Racing clamp puts it a notch below the one-piece VPI
clamp in terms of ease of use, the sonic payback is well worth the
additional effort.
I could certainly
speculate as to the physical goings on which allow the Round Things
record clamp to quite clearly outperform the stock VPI clamp (the
ability of the fibrous material used by Black Diamond Racing to more
effectively damp motor and bearing induced micro-vibrations, as well
as those which result from the stylus/vinyl interface itself, for
example), but the clamp's musical, rather than scientific,
contributions are what concerns us here, and it is the former which
proved nothing short of profound.
Listening The
mid to lower bass region, so vital to music's bloom, body, and
bravado, had a degree of weight and tautness with the Round Things
clamp which was merely hinted at by the stock VPI clamp. I won't use
the oft-abused "the bass plummeted another octave" cliché
so favored by the superlative of the month club, as that would
certainly be an overstatement. While the VPI Aries' already-superb
bottom end extension was subjectively improved by the Round
Things, it was the quality, rather than the quantity, of the bass
which benefited most. With the VPI clamp at the helm, bass drum and
timpani strikes, as well as plucked double bass lines, were rendered
in a slightly rounded, inarticulate manner not reminiscent of the live
experience. In contrast, the Black Diamond Racing clamp offered a
tighter, more articulate presentation, devoid of the moderate, but
audible, blur and overhang heard with the VPI clamp.
Owing to its more
faithful treatment of both high and low frequency transients, the
Round Things imparted a feeling of energy and life to analogue
playback not heard with the VPI clamp. The Round Things' portrayal of
the finale of Mahler's First Symphony (Zubin Mehta/Israel
Philharmonic, London CS 7004) bristled with electricity and
excitement, with massed double basses growling intensely, and brass
fanfares blaring convincingly. This same recording, heard with the VPI
clamp in service, lacked verve and vitality, sounding somewhat bland
and dull in comparison. It is often the case that a component or
accessory which imparts a feeling of vim and vigor to musical playback
does so as a result of etching high-frequency transients. Not so with
the Round Things. High-frequency transients heard with the carbon
fiber clamp had a degree of smoothness and naturalness unmatched by
the VPI clamp, removing the slight edge and glare heard with the
latter during the massed brass passages of the aforementioned Mahler
First Symphony.
The Round Things'
ability to control the inevitable vibrations and resonances associated
with vinyl replay allowed the VPI Aries to effortlessly unravel the
heretofore unknown wealth of musical detail buried deep within the
dense orchestral constructions of Mahler and Anton Bruckner. The
multi-layered sonorities of Bruckner's Fourth Symphony
(Bernard Haitink/Concertgebouw, Philips 835 385 LY), for example, were
more readily heard as individual, yet consonant, musical passages, as
opposed to the more homogenized whole heard with the stock VPI clamp.
Conclusion It
is certainly ironic that as phono cartridges have evolved to the point
of being able to detect and electrically transform groove modulations
of atomic proportions, they have also become more effective at
detecting micro-vibrations generated from within the vinyl replay
system itself. While much progress has, in fact, been made in
physically isolating the electrical transducer from the turntable's
drive system, as well as damping resonances in the vinyl disc itself,
Black Diamond Racing's Round Things record clamp has made it clear
that even a superbly engineered and mechanically-isolated turntable
like the VPI Aries is not immune to the ill effects of self-induced
vibration and resonance. Indeed, the sonic effect of the carbon fiber
clamp on the sound of the Aries was profound (equally so on two
different vintages of VPI's TNT to which I was fortunate enough to
have access prior to the formal review period). With the Round Things
in place of the stock VPI clamp, music had a newfound energy and
vitality without the side-effects of edge or glare, mid and lower bass
energy was more focused resulting in better low-end articulation, and
complex orchestral passages were more readily unraveled - rather
impressive for a device which is, after all, comprised of nothing more
than two pieces of machined carbon fiber!
While I do not consider
myself an inveterate tweaker (I don't dress my cables in jackets or
ties, nor do I feel the need to randomly distribute pocket change atop
my loudspeakers), I have found the sonic improvement wrought by the
Round Things record clamp to far exceed its nominal asking price. I
recommend it highly to owners of VPI turntables wishing to get the
most from their analogue front ends.
|