|
I have long
admired the turntable designs of VPI's Harry Weisfeld. From
the entry-level HW-19, in its myriad incarnations, to the
state-of-the-art TNT Mk.IV, each design embodies ingenuity,
deceptive simplicity, and striking beauty. As a devotee of the
analogue faith, I have also admired Weisfeld's steadfast
commitment to vinyl playback - a commitment which has
withstood the best of times and the worst of times throughout
the LP's checkered past and present.
The Aries is
another in a long line of Weisfeld success stories. Utilizing
the same platter, bearing, and separate motor assembly as
VPI's TNT Mk.IV, but foregoing the latter's air suspension,
the Aries is, in the words of Weisfeld, a "mini TNT".
With a smaller footprint and a substantially lower price than
the TNT, the Aries is an attractive alternative for those who
long for a high degree of the elder sibling's sonic magic,
without its imposing cost or physical presence.
As
was the TNT before it, the Aries is a marvel of visual and
industrial design. Its massive platter, composed of lead,
aluminum and acrylic, floats gracefully over a rounded plinth
constructed from two-inch thick MDF. A ten-gauge steel plate
is bonded to the underside of the plinth for the purposes of
damping and stabilization, and the plinth is finished with
three layers of polished black polyester. The bearing utilized
in the Aries is machined to the highest of tolerances and
features Rulon bushings, a stainless steel shaft, and a
tungsten-carbide thrust plate. The left side of the Aries'
plinth contains a rounded cutout into which its separate motor
assembly is placed (the assembly is one inch shorter and four
pounds lighter than that used in the TNT), maintaining the
turntable's reasonably-sized footprint without the need to
couple the motor to the plinth. As Weisfeld and others have
known for some time, decoupling a turntable's motor from its
plinth prevents the former's inevitable vibrations from being
transmitted through the plinth to the stylus - a device which
is, after all, unable to differentiate between motor-borne
vibrations and those resulting from the LP's microscopic
groove modulations. In the case of the Aries, the motor
assembly is tethered to the platter using a rubber drive belt,
the latter coated with talcum powder to ensure a relatively
constant frictional force against the rotating platter.
Eschewing
vacuum hold-down, VPI instead opts for a mechanical clamp
which couples the vinyl LP to the Aries' platter via its
threaded spindle. Although the VPI clamp is quite effective at
coupling vinyl to platter, as well as flattening mildly warped
records during playback, the sound of the Aries (and, I
suspect, other VPI turntables) is markedly improved through
the use of Black Diamond Racing's "Round Things"
record clamp, soon to be the subject of a full review in this
journal. Both the VPI and Black Diamond Racing clamps require
that a small washer-like rubber ring (supplied with the Aries)
be placed over the spindle and against the platter to prevent
any "dishing" of the vinyl disc as the clamp is
secured. Curiously, no mention of this small device is made in
VPI's otherwise excellent documentation.
Unlike several
of VPI's other models, the Aries contains no sprung or air
suspension. Instead, four height-adjustable, aluminum cone
footers (the tips of which are hardened steel balls), in
conjunction with a neoprene damping material, act to isolate
the Aries from its environment. According to VPI, the neoprene
is not quite as effective an isolator as springs, but it
provides "greater focus and tighter bass." While the
Aries' lack of a true suspension mandates careful placement,
the result is a turntable which, in stark contrast to the Rube
Goldberg-like machines offered by other turntable vendors, is
trivial to setup and maintain.
Setup of the
Aries can be accomplished in mere minutes. Installation of the
platter is a matter of simply aligning the white dot on its
bottom with the corresponding dot on the spindle's top plate,
and lowering it onto the spindle. Although the dot on the
bottom of the platter is not visible once the platter nears
the spindle, approximate alignment is readily achieved and is
more than adequate, according to VPI. With the platter
successfully installed, the turntable is then placed onto its
support, and the separate motor assembly positioned within the
round cutout on the left side of the plinth. The aggregate
turntable/motor assembly is then leveled by whatever means the
support allows (be it threaded spikes, air bladders, etc.),
with final adjustments being made with the Aries'
variable-height cone footers. All that remains is to couple
the motor to the platter by wrapping the belt around the
motor's pulley and the platter's outside edge. Although the
outside edge of the platter is grooved to presumably accept
the belt, VPI claims that the belt need not ride in a groove
for correct operation - once the platter begins to rotate, one
simply allows the belt to find its "natural"
location on the platter's rim. Maintaining the Aries is just
as uncomplicated as its setup - merely ensure it remains
level, and re-talc the belt periodically - nothing more need
be done.
Careful
placement of the Aries is required if it is to be adequately
isolated from the vibrational turbulence of its environment. I
chose to use an Arcici Lead(less) balloon with an Air Head
isolation base for the purposes of this evaluation. With four
independently adjustable air bladders (through high-quality
Schrader valves), the Air Head is ideal for leveled support
and isolation of a turntable like the Aries, which has a
grossly uneven weight distribution caused by its appreciable
left-placed motor assembly. The Air Head's air bladders also
appear to be highly immune to leakage - few times throughout
the many months that the Air Head supported the circa 85 lb.
Aries did its bladders require a small puff of air to restore
their optimum level. The Air Head proved highly effective at
isolation, with even the deepest of bass notes failing to
cause any noticeable acoustic breakthrough. I have little
doubt that Steve Klein's passive or active Vibraplanes would
also serve the Aries well, although their lofty price tags
would seem somewhat prohibitive in the context of this
relatively affordable super-table.
In typical VPI
fashion, several upgrades are available for the Aries, each
purporting to take the turntable to a higher level of
performance. The outboard flywheel, said to provide
substantially better isolation of motor and platter, can be
added at a cost of $1000. VPI believes firmly that the
flywheel is the most substantial Aries upgrade, going so far
as to recommend that it be purchased before a top-notch
tonearm like their own JMW. It should be pointed out, however,
that the flywheel will compromise the small footprint of the
Aries, requiring another six inches of space to the left of
the plinth.
The separate
power line conditioner or PLC, whose goal is to feed the Aries
a pure 60Hz sine wave, free of the fluctuations normally found
at the typical wall outlet, can be had for approximately $600.
An improved version of the unit is said to be in the works, a
prototype of which is to be shown at Hi-Fi '98 (price yet to
be determined). The Aries as tested sported neither the
flywheel nor the PLC, the latest revision of the latter to be
the subject of a future review.
Associated
Components
Analogue:
VPI Aries turntable, Audioquest tonearm, Benz-Micro MC
Gold moving coil cartridge, Black Diamond Racing "Round
Things" record clamp
Preamplifier: Audible Illusions Modulus 3A with
John Curl designed gold MC phono board Power
Amplifiers: Celeste Moon W-5, Sonic Frontiers Power 2
Loudspeakers: ProAc Studio 150, Meadowlark Audio
Shearwater Cables:
D Lin Audio Silver Bullets 4.0 interconnects,
Transparent Audio MusicWave Plus , Audioquest Midnight
Biwire loudspeaker cables, Cardas Hex 5C phono
interconnect.
Accessories: Echo Busters room treatment products,
Lead(less) Balloon turntable stand with Air Head isolation
base, Target equipment stands, Black Diamond Racing Mk.III
and Mk.IV Pyramid Cones, Nitty Gritty 2.5Fi Mk.II record
cleaning machine, Nitty Gritty Pure-2 cleaning fluid,
Stylast stylus treatment, 15A dedicated AC outlets.
|
Listening The
VPI Aries lends much credence to the belief that it is the
turntable, not the tonearm or cartridge, that is of supreme
importance when it comes to the faithful extraction of an LP's
embedded analogue signal. While the Audioquest PT-6 tonearm
and Benz-Micro MC Gold phono cartridge used for this
evaluation are both budget overachievers, they are more likely
to find their way into a relatively modest analogue front end
than one with state-of-the-art aspirations. Yet under the
expert guidance of the Aries, the performance of both the PT-6
and MC Gold was elevated to a level which was quite unexpected
- leaps and bounds, in fact, ahead of their performance when
partnered with lesser turntables. Little wonder that VPI
highly recommends the budget Audioquest arm for use on both
the Aries and TNT if VPI's own JMW proves financially
prohibitive.
If forced to
summarize the sound of the Aries in one phrase, it would have
to be "a vanishingly low noise floor with no obvious
colorations." The vinyl roar which I took for granted
with my previous reference (the sometimes sonically-excellent
but frustratingly-fussy Linn LP12) was reduced to
near-inaudibility by the Aries, allowing fine nuances and
subtle musical detail, once obscured, to be revealed for the
first time. Fine pressings, such as many of the Classic and
Decca Records reissues, portrayed an almost ghostly background
silence, prompting several listeners (myself included) to
liken this quality of the Aries' presentation to that of the
digital medium. I have little doubt that the Aries'
exceedingly high signal-to-noise ratio owes much to the
physical separation of motor and platter, although its
high-tolerance bearing and nearly-imperturbable, low-resonance
platter are also likely contributors.
Besides serving
as a topic of fervent audiophile discussion, the Aries' almost
eerie quiet served the music exceedingly well. From the
brilliant pianissimo passages of Chopin's Ballades
(Arthur Rubinstein, RCA LSC-2370) to the subtle shadings of
Ravel's Rapsodie Espagnole (Decca SXL-2312), the
Aries' ability to simply factor vinyl's all-too-common noise
out of the musical equation was, in my experience, second to
none.
The euphonic
colorations inherent in decks like the Linn LP12, such as an
elevated mid-bass, and an overly ripe midrange, are simply
things of the past with the Aries at the head of the playback
chain. Whether it the gravely, southern-inflected delivery of
a Muddy Waters blues (Folk Singer, Mobile Fidelity
MFSL 1-201), or the warm caress of a Janis Ian folk ballad (Breaking
Silence, Acoustic Sounds APP 027), the Aries' midrange
timbres, textures and tonality were spot-on. Although some may
miss the warmth and sense of body that a bloated midrange and
upper-bass convey, they are, after all, distortions (arguably
pleasant ones) and have no place in a playback system whose
goal is faithful reproduction of the musical source.
As with other
components which value truth over beauty, the Aries'
unwillingness to tell a sonic lie did prove to be a
double-edged sword. Recordings which were decidedly sub-par,
but nonetheless listenable on lesser turntables, often proved
intolerable, each flaw laid to bare by VPI's precision
analogue instrument. The Aries' veracity aligned with this
reviewer's belief that a component which faithfully delivers
its input signal, warts and all, will, in the long term, prove
more satisfying than one which diminishes the quality of all
recordings to a common level of sonic mediocrity.
The Aries
appeared to exhibit none of the artifacts one normally
associates with ill-controlled resonances or undesired energy
storage - namely, transient smearing, loss of inner detail, or
lack of low-end definition. In fact, I have yet to hear a more
finely detailed and articulate presentation from another
analogue or digital source, this holding true even at the
frequency extremes, where digital's theoretical superiority is
said to exist. Furthermore, the Aries' portrayal of dynamic
contrasts was nothing short of stunning. Transitions from
ppp
to fff,
and back again, were as nimble and precise as changes on the
gearbox of a fine German sports car. Nowhere was this more
evident than during the opening and final movements of
Rachmaninoff's Symphonic Dances (Athena ALSW-10001).
Rachmaninoff certainly did not go quietly into that good night
with this, his last and most dynamically challenging score.
The Aries tracked the schizophrenic volume changes in this
brilliant music with nary a loss of control, precision, or
detail, delivering the finest account of this superb recording
I have yet heard. Microdynamics fared just as well as those on
a larger scale, the Aries never shortchanging the more subtle,
yet equally important, low-level changes in volume at the
heart of much classical and jazz repertoire.
While there are
those who claim that analogue is severely bandwidth-limited
and incapable of reaching the highest highs and the lowest
lows, my time with the VPI Aries proved quite the opposite.
Indeed, with the appropriate source material, the Aries
astounded with its ability to effortlessly communicate
frequencies from the subterranean to the stratospheric. The
sub-30Hz bass notes on Enya's Watermark (WEA
24-38751), for example, were easily negotiated, sounding as
thunderous and well-defined as the associated equipment and
listening room would allow. The deep bass passages contained
on Keith Johnson's brilliantly engineered Arnold Overtures
(Reference Recordings RR-48) and Holst's Hammersmith
(Reference Recordings RR-39) were also rendered superbly by
the Aries, each challenging, but never conquering, Weisfeld's
impressive creation. And what of the Aries' presentation of
the high frequencies? As with the low end of the spectrum, the
top end elicited by the Aries was extended and
finely-filigreed, with neither an unnatural sparkle nor an
excitement-robbing dullness. Top-end air and detail were
exceptional, the Aries delivering a superb rendering of
instruments high in frequency, such as bells, cymbals, and
triangles. The brushed cymbal which closes All Roads to
the River from Janis Ian's Breaking Silence, had a
natural sheen and nearly-endless shimmer which was nothing
short of spectacular. The snare drum deep in the soundstage on
A Sussex Overture from Arnold Overtures, was
crisp, tight and bathed in appropriate amounts of hall
ambience, as was the struck wood block on the same track,
whose realism proved startling.
Comparisons The
question remains as to the Aries' place among its
similarly-priced competition. My previous reference, the Linn
LP12/Valhalla, is, when set-up adequately by a Scots-trained
tweakologist, capable of superb sonics. Unfortunately, the
Linn is more colored in the mid-bass than the Aries (and other
top turntables for that matter) and leans decidedly towards
the warm side of neutral. Furthermore, the LP12's initial
magic is soon lost as its sprung suspension slowly, but quite
surely, drifts from its optimal set-up. As for upgrades, Linn
has admirably continued to make them available. In some cases,
however (most notably the Lingo power supply), their cost has
rivaled that of the turntable itself.
The somewhat
quirky but beautifully engineered Well-Tempered Turntable
elegantly and uniquely solves many of the difficult problems
associated with vinyl replay. But while it can sound quite
exceptional, it is finicky to set up (especially its tonearm)
and, as with the venerable Scottish deck, ultimately fails to
achieve the same level of sonic neutrality and background
silence as the Aries.
There are, of
course, other turntables in and around the Aries' price range
which are worthy of consideration, notably the Rega Planar 9
and entry-level offerings in the Basis 2000 series. While I
have yet to audition either of these at length, only the Basis
would appear to offer anything like the Aries' near
lab-instrument build quality, advanced use of materials, and
modular (read upgradeable) design.
Conclusion
Although the Aries may
be viewed by some as the poor brother of the TNT, it is, in
some ways, Harry Weisfeld's crowning achievement. More than
simply a product of trickle-down technology, the Aries is a
true advance of sorts - a product which offers near
state-of-the-art performance at a real-world price. The Aries'
lack of coloration across the frequency band, coupled to its
standard-setting background silence and ease of set-up and
maintenance, make it an easy recommendation for those who
would rather listen to music than adjust springs, pumps or
attempt to defy gravity. As with the HW-19 and TNT, the Aries
is a benchmark product at its price point, one which will call
this reviewer's system "home" for years to come.
|